Catalina de Aragon – Founding the Tudor Blueprint for Female Education


Everyone at least slightly acquainted with British history will know the name of Catherine of Aragon or Catalina de Aragón, if one prefers the original sounding. She made her historical debut as the young bride of the ill-fated Arthur, Prince of Wales. After his passing she would remarry his younger brother, the future king Henry VIII and ascend together with him as the Spanish Queen Consort of England; yet what did that position entail? Catalina had many duties as queen: meetings with foreign ambassadors, hosting and entertaining guests at court festivities, acting as a regent if needed, and paramount amongst them all, bearing an heir to the throne. Pursuant to this duty Catalina had six documented pregnancies, however only one child would survive to adulthood, Mary Tudor, future Queen of England. While Henry VIII did not hold a high opinion of female heirs, Catalina not only loved and cherished her daughter – she revolutionised how royal women were educated for Mary.
But to understand what ‘revolutionised’ implies, one should look at what a typical Tudor princess of her time was taught. Of course, all wealthy families relied on private teachers, who often came from abroad. Knowledge of languages was valued perhaps most of all - for both men and women - but usually it was limited to French, and some familiarity with Latin, usually only several gospels from the Book of Prayers. Languages were followed by lessons in literature, religion, and music - alongside typical ‘women’s’ skills such as needlework. One may ask “but did not royal boys study the same, languages, religion, literature”? Indeed so; yet the purposes were completely different. A Tudor princess was educated to make her an attractive bride - to be able to converse with foreign suitors or ambassadors, to dance, and quote beautiful verses. While a prince, a potential king, needed Greek and Latin to analyse civil law, theology, and classical literature such as Plato instead of the chivalric medieval romances proposed for princesses. Additionally, men’s education was laced with history and politics, something that did not necessarily appear in the ladies' curriculum. As the title of the article implies, Catalina de Aragón was the one who changed that. But why did Catalina feel so strongly about reforming Princess Mary’s and, in essence, women’s education as a whole?
Perhaps the answer lies in an education young Catalina received herself.
In her youth, Catalina received an invaluable education, not too dissimilar to one received by her mother, Isabella of Castile, who was a woman of sophisticated views and wanted to embrace the same standards for her daughter. Catalina was taught multiple languages; Latin and Greek alongside her native Castilian Spanish. Latin was used as the language of international diplomacy so many royal women learned it due to its ubiquity in international communications and politics. Greek was learned to read the original biblical texts, study classical philosophy and science (like the works of Aristotle or Plato) without medieval errors, as well as to engage with the Christian Humanism movement. Additionally when Catalina was only just preparing to venture to England, her future mother-in-law Elizabeth of York, wrote to Spain suggesting that Catalina learn French as ladies in the English court were unfamiliar with Latin, so it could not be used as an intermediary. All these areas of study were rarely taught even to royal women, and something that Tudor ladies did not have an access to, as philosophy, classical science, and deeper religious studies were reserved for men. Catalina, however, was taught those classes as part of her education.
Now, it would be quite easy to imagine that Mary Tudor would receive the same education as her mother and grandmother, especially once it became clear that Mary would be an only child. An exact age cannot be given for when Mary Tudor began her extraordinary education, however we can almost be certain the princess started at a tender age. Historian Linda Porter notes how at the age of four, she could play the virginals and would go on to learn the regal and the lute; by the age of nine, she could read and write Latin; and at around twelve-years-old, she translated a Latin prayer by St. Thomas Aquinas. Not only did Mary learn languages, she also became fluent in them: something that was not always expected from English noblewomen before her. In 1531, Mario Savagno wrote of Mary:
“[she] speaks Latin, French and Spanish, besides her own mother-English tongue and is well-grounded in Greek and understands Italian but does not venture to speak it. She sings excellently and plays on several musical instruments, so that she combines every accomplishment.”
Another important thing to understand about how Catalina wanted her daughter to be educated was the humanist curriculum - a programme of education inspired by Renaissance humanism, a movement that began in Italy and spread across Europe during the 14th-16th centuries. It meant that a pupil not only learnt practical skills, such as needlework, music, manners, and household management; it also embraced intellectual development, beauty of language, and moral values. This said curriculum reached England only with Catalina’s arrival, for that was how she herself was taught; this may explain why her vision could be considered ‘radical’ for the time. Mary Tudor also studied Christian doctrine in depth while, before her, ladies were limited to learning prayers and devotional reading. A careful reader may have noticed that a specific attention in this paragraph was laid on the depth of study - for what also differed in Mary’s education overall was that everything she learned was taught to her in depth, while the girls before her were limited by rather superficial explanations. At this point, Catalina’s idea about Mary’s education was not simply to have her daughter tutored to some basic understanding of the chosen subjects, rather her education remained more of an academic one, especially because the royal court could afford the acquisition of expensive books and sources, such as classical Latin authors.
If we look at the choices Catalina made choosing her daughter’s tutors, there are a number of note. For Latin, Mary had Thomas Linacre, an English Renaissance physician, who founded the Royal College of Physicians in London, having previously translated several medical works into Latin. Specifically for Mary Tudor, Linacre wrote the Rudimenta Grammatices textbook. Richard Fetherstone was her schoolmaster for some time; he was later executed by Henry VIII for he vehemently opposed the break up with Rome. Giles Duwes, who had taught French to Arthur, Henry VIII, and, subsequently, Mary, wrote her a grammar text titled ‘An Introductorie for to lerne to rede, to pronounce and to speke French trewly, compyled for the right high, excellent and most vertuous lady the Lady Mary of Englande, doughter of our most gracious soverayn Lorde Kyng Henry the Eight’. But the key role in Mary’s education was played by Juan Vives, whom Catalina commissioned for constructing a curriculum for her daughter; Juan was one of the people who through their writings helped to establish the ‘humanist curriculum’ in Europe. One of his most important works is De Institutione Feminae Christianae (The Education of a Christian Woman) and, while he does not leave the view that every girl should become a good wife and mother, he believes that every woman should receive a thorough education alongside teachings of conduct and manners for unmarried, married, and widowed ladies.
Therefore, the most important question remaining to be asked is how did the education embraced by Catalina actually influence her daughter?
Ultimately, even though Mary was not expected to become a Queen, history decided otherwise. It was her studies of Latin, classical scholars, and deep Christian doctrine that would allow her to present herself as a learned and a cultivated ruler. Mary Tudor, now Mary I, was treated with respect by European institutions and kingdoms for the knowledge and morals implemented to her since early childhood. Since Catholic values were so strongly empathised by Vives in her education, Mary I became known as a staunch Catholic ruler, reintroducing Catholic bishops and restoring the authority of the pope in England, an action warmly welcomed by many states that backed the counter-reformation movement. And, of course, Mary I set another example of how to be a queen in her own right. She demonstrated that a woman is able to be well-educated, to discuss the same literature as the European kings discussed, to understand the same religious texts that were taught to princes, and, most of all, to govern a country.
Nonetheless, while Catalina definitely encouraged the promotion of the idea that women could and should receive a serious education, it is difficult to argue that it was her actions alone that suddenly transformed the Tudor court, or royal education of the future generations. While women began to receive a deeper access to sources, and in some aspects the inequalities between women and men were somewhat lessened in this regard, it was clear that true educational equality between the sexes was still not close at hand. Nor did Catalina’s efforts to educate her daughter change access to tutors, books and classical languages which remained largely dependent on wealth and social status. Although it was only in the mid-17th century, where women’s education faced a serious and shameful drawback, Catalina’s programme did nothing to reject conventional expectations that women should be religious, chaste and prepared for marriage.
References:
https://circeinstitute.org/blog/blog-surprising-thoughts-female-education-middle-ages/
https://www.europeana.eu/pl/stories/the-fascination-with-greek-culture
https://www.historyskills.com/classroom/year-8/tudor-women-education/
https://tudorblogger.com/2014/10/19/the-relationship-between-mary-i-and-katherine-of-aragon/
https://repository.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2089&context=gradschool_theses
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/0895769X.2011.540501


Comments